NYTimes: Older, but No More Mature
But mostly this is a straight-up re-creation of the off-kilter world of the original series, which managed to succeed as both a sincere, pedagogical children’s show and a winking sendup of one at the same time. It was a remarkable magic trick that won the show an avid following both among real tykes and adults who warmed to Mr. Reubens’s kitschy, mildly subversive take on a vintage formula.
The key ingredient was — is — Pee-wee himself, a being forever arrested at the age of development when sarcasm has just been discovered — it’s yummier than chocolate! — and sex remains an obscure mystery, some unnecessary adult variation on cooties. (Which does not mean that the occasional naughty double entendre cannot be lobbed over the heads of the little ones.)
Mr. Reubens’s Silly Putty face is a little puttier, but it remains as stretchable as ever. His Popsicle-stick posture retains its comical rigidity; the flapping arms express exasperation and excitement with no loss of tone; the bopping Pee-wee dance is still beach-ball-buoyant. And of course Pee-wee’s restless imagination and childish mood swings are as extravagant as ever.
Gasps of delight and bursts of welcoming applause greet the three original cast members on hand to recreate their roles: John Moody as Mailman Mike, Mr. Paragon as Jambi the Genie and Lynne Marie Stewart as Miss Yvonne, “the most beautiful woman in Puppetland.” Some of these players are perhaps showing the years a little more glaringly than Mr. Reubens himself. (Raspberried cheeks and white powder do wonders for erasing age, or perhaps the key is to find a strong signature look and stick to it.) But then the fans in the audience may reflect on the faces that greet them in the morning mirror, whether they caught the show during their actual tykehood or as young adults who cottoned to its mind-clearing appeal as a procrastination aid during the college years.
There are also newcomers to old roles, like Phil LaMarr as Cowboy Curtis, and Lance Roberts as the King of Cartoons, and newcomers to new roles, notably Jesse Garcia as Sergio the Handyman. (“Pee-wee’s Playhouse” was notable for its racial inclusiveness, and Mr. Herman continues to fly a rainbow banner here.)
The Pee-wee-ignorant or the Pee-wee-averse are definitely not invited to the party. At times I felt a bit like a wallflower myself. I knew Pee-wee primarily from his debut movie, “Pee-wee’s Big Adventure,” Tim Burton’s breakthrough film, and was disappointed that the stage show featured little in the way of adventure, which is to say plot. The production is just a merry jumble of beloved bits designed to push the audience’s buttons with their familiarity. (Some date all the way back to the original “Pee-wee Herman Show,” staged in Los Angeles in 1981.) A string of unrelated diversions can be perfectly pleasing in a half-hour dose, but after 90 minutes I began to feel like a fidgety kid in need of an Adderall fix.
But I don’t want to sprinkle too much rain on the reunion parade in Puppetland occasioned by the return of the happy prince. The wandering focus of “The Pee-Wee Herman Show” will not be a distraction for fans of Mr. Reubens’s perky parody of a goofy kid. Nobody expects Pee-wee to prepare and polish a thesis during morning recess.
THE PEE-WEE HERMAN SHOW
Created and conceived by Paul Reubens; written by Mr. Reubens and Bill Steinkellner, with additional material by John Paragon; directed by Alex Timbers; music by Jay Cotton; sets by David Korins; costumes by Ann Closs-Farley; lighting by Jeff Croiter; sound by M. L. Dogg; puppets by Basil Twist; projections by Jake Pinholster; technical supervision by Larry Morley and Sam Ellis; design consultant, Jimmy Cuomo; cartoon and film consultant, Prudence Fenton; makeup, hair and wig design by Ve Neill and Cookie Jordan; associate producers, Jared Geller, David J. Foster, Anne Caruso and Kelly Bush. Presented by Scott Sanders Productions, Adam S. Gordon, Allan S. Gordon, Élan V. McAllister, Roy Miller, Carol Fineman, Scott Zeilinger Productions/Radio Mouse Entertainment and StylesFour Productions/Randy Donaldson/Tim Laczynski. At the Stephen Sondheim Theater, 124 West 43rd Street, Manhattan; (212) 239-6200; telecharge.com. Through Jan. 2. Running time: 1 hour 30 minutes.
WITH: Paul Reubens (Pee-wee Herman), Lynne Marie Stewart (Miss Yvonne), Phil LaMarr (Cowboy Curtis), Jesse Garcia (Sergio), Josh Meyers (Firefighter), John Moody (Mailman Mike), John Paragon (Jambi), Drew Powell (Bear) and Lance Roberts (King of Cartoons).